{"@context":"https://schema.org","@graph":[{"@type":"BlogPosting","@id":"https://www.rivertreewealth.com/blog/skipping-roth-conversions-retirement-spending#article","headline":"Why Skipping Roth Conversions Can Make Sense With $2.5M Saved","description":"Roth conversions may not pay off if they keep you from living your retirement. See how higher spending cut one couple's conversion benefit in half.","image":"https://i.ytimg.com/vi/4IqKA_A5fyw/maxresdefault.jpg","datePublished":"2026-09-05T17:00:31.000Z","dateModified":"2026-09-05T17:00:31.000Z","mainEntityOfPage":"https://www.rivertreewealth.com/blog/skipping-roth-conversions-retirement-spending","url":"https://www.rivertreewealth.com/blog/skipping-roth-conversions-retirement-spending","author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Jacob Duke, CFP®","jobTitle":"Founder & Lead Advisor","url":"https://www.rivertreewealth.com/about-us","sameAs":["https://www.youtube.com/@RetirementAnswers","https://www.linkedin.com/in/jacobduke/","https://open.spotify.com/show/6a5BQ6ezlhiVyNyW5uxW16"]},"publisher":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Rivertree Wealth","url":"https://www.rivertreewealth.com","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","url":"https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/682605e780a05a1c8f5c3928/68a23248df703dcdcfe0ed7c_Rivertree%20Logo%20Full%20-%20Primary%20Color.png"}},"articleSection":"Roth Conversions","keywords":"Skipping Roth Conversions: When Spending Wins"},{"@type":"FAQPage","@id":"https://www.rivertreewealth.com/blog/skipping-roth-conversions-retirement-spending#faq","mainEntity":[{"@type":"Question","name":"Do I have to do Roth conversions in retirement?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Not necessarily. Roth conversions can help with tax jumps from RMDs or the widow's tax trap, but they are a tool, not a requirement. In an illustrative case study of a retired couple with upwards of $2.7 million invested, adding 22% bracket conversions on top of their dream-retirement spending had a negative long-term impact. Building the lifestyle and income plan first, then checking for conversion room, may lead to a different answer."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"How does spending more in retirement affect Roth conversions?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Higher spending can reduce the benefit of Roth conversions. In one hypothetical example, raising monthly spending from $7,500 to $10,000 cut the end-of-life benefit of converting to the 22% bracket from about $510,000 to about $271,000, roughly half. When the couple's full dream budget was added, the 22% conversions had a negative long-term impact, paying a little less in taxes but leaving them with less money."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"Is the 24% tax bracket a good bracket for Roth conversions?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"It depends on the plan. For many people, the 24% bracket is a break-over point where returns on the conversion diminish. In one illustrative case, converting to 24% lowered lifetime taxes but left the tax-adjusted ending balance about the same, because of the taxes paid on the conversions. The 22% bracket looked like the better stopping point, and converting at 24% while also spending more would likely hurt."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"What is a comfortable probability of success for a retirement plan?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Jacob Duke, CFP, says 83% is not a scary number to him. He is comfortable when a plan is north of 80% and considers 85% to 90% a really comfortable range, partly because these models don't account for human intervention or changes of course along the way. In one hypothetical dream-retirement plan, an 83% result still supported vacations, a remodel, and new cars."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"What is tax over-optimization in retirement?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Tax over-optimization is when trying to minimize taxes starts to drive retirement decisions, such as squeezing every bit of juice out of an IRA, chasing the perfect Roth conversion plan, or minimizing health insurance premiums no matter what it takes. The risk is that vacations, home projects, and family time get postponed. A life-first plan treats taxes as a secondary item after spending and income goals."}}]},{"@type":"VideoObject","@id":"https://www.rivertreewealth.com/blog/skipping-roth-conversions-retirement-spending#video","name":"Why I’m Skipping Roth Conversions With $2.5M in My 401k","description":"Roth conversions get treated as a must, but they can cost you the retirement you saved for. This illustrative case study shows how real spending goals can shrink or erase the conversion benefit.","thumbnailUrl":"https://i.ytimg.com/vi/4IqKA_A5fyw/maxresdefault.jpg","uploadDate":"2026-09-05T17:00:31.000Z","duration":"PT12M47S","embedUrl":"https://www.youtube.com/embed/4IqKA_A5fyw","contentUrl":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4IqKA_A5fyw"}]}
Roth Conversions
Blog Category

Why Skipping Roth Conversions Can Make Sense With $2.5M Saved

Roth conversions get treated as a must, but they can cost you the retirement you saved for. This illustrative case study shows how real spending goals can shrink or erase the conversion benefit.

Watch on YouTube Listen to the podcast

Key takeaways

  • Tax over-optimization, or the tax tail wagging the life dog, happens when avoiding taxes starts driving retirement decisions instead of your life goals.
  • In this hypothetical case, raising monthly spending from $7,500 to $10,000 cut the end-of-life benefit of converting to the 22% bracket from about $510,000 to about $271,000.
  • For many people, the 24% bracket is a break-over point where Roth conversions lower lifetime taxes but leave the tax-adjusted ending balance about the same.
  • With a full dream-retirement budget, adding 22% bracket conversions had a negative long-term impact in this example, while the plan still showed an 83% probability of success.
  • A life-first approach builds the spending and income plan first, then looks for room to do Roth conversions at whatever bracket.

Here is something that sounds counterintuitive coming from a retirement planner: you may not need the kind of tax plan you think you do. What I see plaguing many retirees is tax over-optimization, squeezing every bit of juice out of an IRA, dialing up the perfect Roth conversion plan, or trying to minimize health insurance premiums no matter what it takes.

What I've seen with clients is that this focus can quietly cost more than they realize. Nobody saves for 30 or 40 years thinking, "I just can't wait to start doing my Roth conversions at 65." They dream about bucket list trips with their spouse, taking the grandkids on a special vacation, or finally starting the garden they've been trying to start for 20 years.

In this article, I'll walk through an illustrative case study showing why putting tax efficiency first can be expensive, and how I think about where Roth conversions fit once your life plan comes first.

What is tax over-optimization in retirement?

Tax over-optimization is when avoiding taxes starts driving your retirement decisions instead of your life goals. I call it the tax tail wagging the life dog.

You finally retire, learn that you could get hit hard by taxes without a plan, and all of your focus shifts to protecting your hard-earned savings from taxes.

You've probably seen a chart like this: taxes jump at 75 and 76 when required minimum distributions (RMDs) kick in, and jump again when one spouse passes away. Looking at that, the answer seems obvious: do Roth conversions now. But that chart doesn't tell you the full picture.

A hypothetical case study: Jack and Jill

To show what the chart misses, consider an illustrative couple I'll call Jack and Jill. They are 64 and 63 and retired last year, in 2025.

  • Cash: $120,000
  • Investments: upwards of $2.7 million, including a small Roth IRA
  • Two rollover IRAs from their 401(k)s: about $1.1 million for Jack and $1.3 million for Jill, which is where most of their money sits
  • Core spending budget: $7,500 per month, fairly modest for their overall assets

They did a great job saving. Now that they're retired, they keep hearing about Roth conversions and the tax bill they could face later, either before one of them passes away or after the widow's tax trap kicks in. So they are hyperfocused on converting.

What you don't see at first glance is that they're not doing the things they otherwise want to do. Their vacation budget is $0. The basement remodel they've put off for years is $0, and they're putting it off again while they figure out whether to do conversions. Their new car budget, for a car every five years, is $0 too.

Can this couple afford to retire?

Yes. On their $7,500 monthly base budget, this example shows no realistic chance of running out of money.

On that budget, the conversion math looks compelling. Filling the 12% bracket shows tax savings and a higher tax-adjusted ending balance for their kids and heirs, which makes it feel like a no-brainer. Filling the 22% bracket saves a lot more in taxes and ends with about the same tax-adjusted amount of money.

The 24% bracket is where it gets interesting. For many people, this is a break-over point where the returns on the conversion start to diminish. In this example, they would pay less in lifetime taxes, but the difference in tax-adjusted ending balance is right around zero, because the taxes paid on the conversions themselves eat up the benefit.

So on the original budget, the 22% bracket is probably where they'd camp out if they were going to convert. The problem is that this analysis assumes they keep skipping the things they dreamed of doing.

How does spending more change the Roth conversion math?

Spending more can shrink the benefit of Roth conversions significantly. In this example, raising the monthly budget by $2,500 cut the end-of-life benefit of converting to the 22% bracket roughly in half.

Phase 1: Raise the monthly budget to $10,000

Increasing spending from $7,500 to $10,000 per month, with none of the extras yet, still showed minimal chances of running out of money.

But the conversion benefit changed. On the $7,500 budget, converting to the 22% bracket showed an end-of-life benefit of about $510,000. With the extra $2,500 per month for the rest of their lives, that benefit dropped to about $271,000, simply because they were spending more money. There was still some benefit to converting up to the 22% bracket at this budget, just a smaller one.

Is that a good or bad thing? I'd argue spending the extra $2,500 per month is a good thing. They're probably enjoying life, starting that garden, and doing things with the grandkids.

Phase 2: Fund the dream retirement

Next, I modeled what they've always thought about doing:

  • $10,000 per month in core spending
  • $15,000 per year for vacations for 15 years, adjusted a little each year for inflation
  • A $150,000 basement remodel in 2027
  • A $60,000 new car every five years, starting in 2027

With this max budget, the plan's probability of success came in at 83%. That's not a scary number in my mind. If we're north of 80%, I'm comfortable, and I like 85% to 90% as a really comfortable range, especially since the model doesn't account for human intervention or changes of course along the way.

The trade-off is real. Instead of potentially $4.2 or $4.3 million at the end of life, they might have about $1.6 million. That can feel scary, but in this example the couple likes the idea of enjoying life more than trying to save a bunch on taxes.

When do Roth conversions not make sense?

Roth conversions may not make sense when they compete with the life you want to live and don't leave you better off in the end. In this example, doing 22% bracket conversions on top of the max budget actually had a negative long-term impact: they would pay a little less in taxes, but it would leave them with less money.

That leads to a simple question. If not spending the money and doing Roth conversions ends in roughly the same place as spending the money and not converting, why not spend it and enjoy it?

Notice the plan doesn't drop conversions entirely. In this illustrative scenario, there is one big conversion in 2026, because most of their goals start the following year, and then minimal conversions until they reach RMD age.

Pushing harder makes it worse. Converting at the 24% bracket because someone said "do as much Roth as you can," while also spending on their goals, would really hurt them.

How should taxes fit into a retirement plan?

In my view, taxes work best as a secondary item: build your life, your spending, and your income plan first, then look for tax savings in whatever room is left.

Build your life, your income plan, all the fun you want to have. Do that first and see if there's any room left to do Roth conversions at whatever bracket.
  1. Build out your life. Include the trips, projects, cars, and family time, not just the base monthly budget.
  2. Build out your spending and income plan. Check whether the plan holds up at the spending level you actually want.
  3. Then look to tax savings. See whether a Roth conversion still adds value, and at which bracket.

Leading with tax savings can be tempting. Ending with as much money as possible, or leaving as big a tax-free legacy as you can, sounds great. But focusing on taxes first could jeopardize your fun, your fulfillment, and the things you could be doing.

The bottom line

Roth conversions can be a valuable tool, but they are a tool, not the goal. As this hypothetical example shows, the right amount to convert can change dramatically once your real spending goals are in the plan.

If everyone has been telling you Roth conversions are great but your own numbers look different, that's worth exploring. You likely have more options than you think. Let taxes fill in the gaps after you've enjoyed each year of retirement.

If you're within five years of retirement and want a second set of eyes on your plan, see if you're a fit to work with Rivertree Wealth.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to do Roth conversions in retirement?

Not necessarily. Roth conversions can help with tax jumps from RMDs or the widow's tax trap, but they are a tool, not a requirement. In an illustrative case study of a retired couple with upwards of $2.7 million invested, adding 22% bracket conversions on top of their dream-retirement spending had a negative long-term impact. Building the lifestyle and income plan first, then checking for conversion room, may lead to a different answer.

How does spending more in retirement affect Roth conversions?

Higher spending can reduce the benefit of Roth conversions. In one hypothetical example, raising monthly spending from $7,500 to $10,000 cut the end-of-life benefit of converting to the 22% bracket from about $510,000 to about $271,000, roughly half. When the couple's full dream budget was added, the 22% conversions had a negative long-term impact, paying a little less in taxes but leaving them with less money.

Is the 24% tax bracket a good bracket for Roth conversions?

It depends on the plan. For many people, the 24% bracket is a break-over point where returns on the conversion diminish. In one illustrative case, converting to 24% lowered lifetime taxes but left the tax-adjusted ending balance about the same, because of the taxes paid on the conversions. The 22% bracket looked like the better stopping point, and converting at 24% while also spending more would likely hurt.

What is a comfortable probability of success for a retirement plan?

Jacob Duke, CFP, says 83% is not a scary number to him. He is comfortable when a plan is north of 80% and considers 85% to 90% a really comfortable range, partly because these models don't account for human intervention or changes of course along the way. In one hypothetical dream-retirement plan, an 83% result still supported vacations, a remodel, and new cars.

What is tax over-optimization in retirement?

Tax over-optimization is when trying to minimize taxes starts to drive retirement decisions, such as squeezing every bit of juice out of an IRA, chasing the perfect Roth conversion plan, or minimizing health insurance premiums no matter what it takes. The risk is that vacations, home projects, and family time get postponed. A life-first plan treats taxes as a secondary item after spending and income goals.

Retirement Answers, in your inbox

Get Jacob's weekly retirement notes

One email a week with plain-English takeaways on taxes, Roth conversions, Social Security and spending in retirement. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Share this article: LinkedIn Facebook X Email

Work with Rivertree

Want a second set of eyes on your retirement plan?

We help people 50+ with $1M or more saved build a retirement plan that coordinates taxes, income, Social Security and investments.

See if you're a fit

Important disclosure: This article is a written summary of a Retirement Answers video or podcast episode by Jacob Duke, CFP®, and is provided for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not personalized investment, tax, or legal advice, and it is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or to adopt any particular strategy.

Any case studies, examples, or projections are hypothetical and for illustrative purposes only. They do not represent actual client results, are not guarantees of future outcomes, and may not reflect your circumstances. Names and details are fictional or have been changed. Projections from planning software depend on assumptions that may not occur.

Tax laws, contribution limits, Medicare premiums, Social Security rules, and other figures change frequently. Information is believed to be accurate as of the original publish date shown above and may now be outdated. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal, and past performance does not guarantee future results. Please consult a qualified financial, tax, or legal professional about your specific situation before acting.

Rivertree Wealth LLC is an SEC-registered investment adviser (CRD #329595). Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Rivertree Wealth LLC does not provide legal advice. Additional information, including our Form CRS and Form ADV Part 2A, is available upon request and at adviserinfo.sec.gov.

No items found.